GunCritic
GunCritic

Benelli 828U VS Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I

Head to Head Comparison

Benelli 828U

Guncritic Icon
84%

Critic Rating

14 Reviews

Guncritic Icon
93%

User Rating

22 Reviews

Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I

Guncritic Icon
86%

Critic Rating

6 Reviews

Guncritic Icon
96%

User Rating

74 Reviews

50 MOA

Accuracy

50 MOA

75.97 Yeets

Damage

41.86 Yeets

50-100 yards

Range

50-100 yards

N/A

Recoil Velocity

N/A

2 rounds

Capacity

2 rounds

-24728

Mobility

1952

50

Ergonomics

50

50

Fit & Finish

50

50

Reliability

50

MSRP:

$2284.19

Used Price:

$2284.19

New Price:

$2537.99

MSRP:

$1797.75

Used Price:

$1797.75

New Price:

$1997.50

Gun Specifications

Specifications

Benelli 828U

Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I

Weight

104 oz

16 oz

Length

41 1/2"

47.75"

Action

Over/Under

Over/Under

Caliber

12 GA

20 GA

Capacity

2

2

Finish

Nickel

Blued

Gun Type

Shotgun

Shotgun

Sights

Fiber Optic Sight

No Sights

Grip

Wood

Barrel Length

26"

30"

Gun Stats

Recently Deals

Benelli 828U

Guns.com

$2537.99

Sportsman's Warehouse

$2537.99

GrabAGun

$2537.99

Optics Planet

$2537.99

Cheaper Than Dirt

$2537.99

Brownells.com

$1529.99

KYGUNCO

$1844.99

EuroOptic.com

$2537.99

Guns.com

$2537.99

Academy Sports + Outdoors

$2537.99

Firearms Depot

$2537.99

Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I

Guns.com

$2056.19

Sportsman's Warehouse

$2056.19

GrabAGun

$1849.00

MidwayUSA

$2449.00

Optics Planet

$2056.19

Cheaper Than Dirt

$2056.19

KYGUNCO

$2173.82

EuroOptic.com

$2056.19

Guns.com

$2056.19

Academy Sports + Outdoors

$2056.19

Firearms Depot

$2056.19

Gun Descriptions

NIB Benelli 828U 12 GA 28 Engraved

The 686 Silver Pigeon I hunting shotgun has all the functional features of our premium over-under at a particularly attractive price. At its heart, it has the best-in-class 686 action, which is compact and low-profile while being extremely strong. Whether you take it to an upland hunt or to the clay range, the Silver Pigeon I gives you the flawless performance and the classic looks of a Beretta.

Suggested Comparisons

Browning Citori 725 vs Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I

Benelli 828U vs Beretta 690

Benelli 828U vs Browning Cynergy

Benelli 828U vs Beretta 686

Browning Citori 725 Field vs Benelli 828U

828U vs 828U Sport

Beretta 690 vs Benelli 828U

Benelli 828U vs Browning Citori 725 Sporting